May 2004
WE
LOVE IT WHEN A PLAN
COMES TOGETHER ....
As this newsletter goes in the mail to
Hanover
for
processing, we have 190 deposit checks in hand, accumulating to an attendance of
370 for the
Dartmouth
50th
Reunion
to end
all 50th reunions. The remaining
names on the Yes and Maybe lists are strong enough for us to ask GARY ROSENTHAL
to energize his hat-makers into action for 260 toppers.
One of the truly satisfying aspects of this phase of the reunion is the
receipt of a check or even a confirming mention about a ‘54 who hasn’t been
on the radar screen for a while, e.g. ANDY GUILLIANO. If you need one more
slight nudge to make the determining decision, think about JOHN GILLESPIE’s
early plans for our 55th: “Bring your own food and scrounge up a het from some
prior reunion ...”.
A few changes in the materials currently in your hands:
-HERB HILLMAN has agreed to handle the tennis activities.
KATHY FAST, thankfully, is in a
recuperative phase from surgery and
STEVE needs to be on hand with her
instead of settling arguments about
lets and outs. Herb is at herbannhil@aol.com; (802) 253-4538
-the 50th Class Address will be delivered at the Saturday luncheon by
DAVE McLAUGHLIN, while my comments will come at the Saturday banquet.
My topic, Musings of a Newsletter Editor may be expanded to include
Lamentations of a Reunion Treasurer.
-the
Hood
Museum
tour
will begin at
2:30
on
Saturday -highly recommended
-RON DUNTON is scrambling, trying to gather a semblance of the Sultans
for some tent sounds. MIKE BIGGS won’t be with us, so the pickin’s are
slender.
BILL WHITE and WAYNE WEIL have done it! The 50th Book has been put to bed
with more than 350 Classmates’ submissions included. The Book should be in the
hands of those providing sketches by late May. While a number of generous
Classmates have stepped and underwritten a goodly portion of the cost of the
Book, each recipient will be asked (nicely) to chip in.
DON and JOIE KELLER have done a little neatening of their lives: “In
December, we sold our
Needham
,
MA
house
and moved to a condo in
Plymouth
. We’re
one town from our youngest son and his family (2-yr old Ben). We are also in the
midst of six golf courses - 2 in Pine hills, one by Rees Jones and another by
young Nicholas. We’ll be there July/Aug, Naples Sep/Oct and back in Plymouth
Nov/Dec. We kept our cottage in
Chatham
, so
we’ll summer-shuttle in the summer.” Successful children and energetic
grandkids.”Don claims credit for the introduction of an ethics examination for
investment managers - brilliant!
DOUG HOSKINS has added to his “artificial parts” with the replacement
of a knee banged u in an auto accident in 1952. He and JOYCE dodged the harsh
Pennsylvania
winter
by luxuriating in
Oaxaca
,
Mexico
for
several weeks. They recommend it highly as a winter destination: “ .... lovely
colonial city in a south central valley of 5000 feet, very low humidity, no
Jan/Feb rain and very friendly people.” They plan to return.
MARILYN and DICK GRASSEY celebrated their 50th wedding anniversary in
Hawaii
. They
Greened it up by doing it conjunction with a
Dartmouth
Alumni
College
trip.
Nice touch.
After teaching law at
Univ.
of
Iowa
in the
60s, DAVE SNOW practiced with Jones, Da in
Cleveland
until
1988, when he mounted the bench as a Federal bankruptcy judge (assuming the
“bkry” on his Greencard means “bankruptcy” and not “bakery”). JOYCE
NEIDITZ, attorney, became wife #2 in 1985. Sensibly, they both decided to smell
the roses in 2000, closed up shop and moved to the Blue hill
Peninsula
in
Maine
: “ ...
where we look across the bay to
Acadia
, read and bike. Many
Dartmouth
alumni
have, surprisingly, retired to this Far North place full-time.”
STAN ROSENBERG has joined the “Over the hill Club” in an effort to
find old people who will ski with him. Sounds like he’s doing just fine with
younger schussers - Vail in December and freezing
Alta
,
Utah
(great
snow) in February. Stan’s still a practicing urological surgeon in
Princeton
,
NJ
.
Rev. DAVE RANSOM has joined JOE MESICS in noting my incorrect use of
“enervate” when I should have written “energize”. Dave, however,
ventures out on a tack that takes the newsletter to a new level. Read carefully
- there will be test at the 50th: “It happens, too, as Philip Pullman’s
millennial cusp trilogy, ‘His Dark Materials’, recalls in describing
‘specters’ or as we may remember in sitting, unmotivated, with pencil in
hand before the best of lecturers or especially vapid presentations, or as one
may experience in hearing the shallow or ‘cheerleading’ types of news
commentary on radio or television and by columnists, or even in the risk of
reconnecting with a classmate.. I find that moment of enervation to be a
judgment against my own ego and possible dullness or plain tiredness, and, when
accepted, a portal to an exciting encounter. We hope that many ‘54s and
families will also accept their fears of moments of even conscious enervation
and prepare to discover the wealth of life that a reunion event can allow.
Our warring world needs the sort of reconnaissance and discovery efforts
which a reunion can provide. Yet, one becomes just plain tired, too, and needs
‘space’, so perhaps the reality of ‘enervate’ is needed as an indication
of the birth of a new energy.”Certainly words to be re-read ....
BOB SPEARS: “Enjoying life in beautiful
Colorado
Springs
. My
youngest daughter (35) got married
12/14/03
! I enjoy
volunteering on several boards and
MALI
and I
love taking cruises. Our next one will be to
Australia
and
New
Zealand
. We also
enjoy bowling on several teams and spent the first two weeks of November in
Matzland
,
Mexico
. All
three of my children live in the
San Diego
area,
which we visit regularly. AL PITZNER is the ‘54 with whom I maintain the
closest contact.”
Professor BOB WHITE is teaching a Creative Writing class at the Council
on Aging in his community. Interesting
thought. Who has more life experiences, opinions, perspective than those who
have lived the longest? Guiding seniors into the creative arena, then handing
them the tools to develop and exercise their natural talents for expression has
to be a most rewarding way to spend one’s days. DELDA continues to serve as
church organist and choir director in
Stoughton
,
MA
.
Letters to the Editors
As a Class, we are beginning to dominate the front part of the Dartmouth
Alumni Magazine with our objections, alternate opinions and independent
thoughts. In the Mar/Apr issue, DOUG
DODGE asked why the dean of Pluralism’s comment that “
Dartmouth
will be
diverse enough when
Dartmouth
no
longer has a ‘majority population’” didn’t amount to a quota system.
In the May/Jun issue, BOB COLLINS, from his perspective of a long career
as a history professor, bewailed the impact the Internet has had on diminishing
the challenges to students’ capacities for writing papers - a few taps on the
keyboard and the machine not only does all the research, it also corrects their
spelling and syntax! Then, in the
same issue, JIM DAVIDSON got a little lighter in his interest in the rope ladder
hung out of the window of the Map Room at Baker to help chipmunks escape. Jim
does the same thing for frogs in his swimming pool with a specially marked
floating seat cushion. With the
abundance of controversial subjects in the May/Jun issue, the Letters to the
Editor section(“Rants and Raves of Readers”) in the next issue may
well outweigh the rest of the magazine.
DANA LOW, who is one of only two Classmates to have traversed the entire
length of the
Appalachian
Trail
(the
other being Rev. DAVE RANSOM, our reunion Moosilauke leader) is about to
share the joy of hiking with grandson Ben. They will begin back-packing
from the family place in
Fairlee
,
VT
and head
north, beyond the end of the Trail, and then at it for three weeks. What a great
grampa to have!
JOHN CUNNINGHAM spent last December and January commuting to the Long
Wharf Theater in
New Haven
, appearing in “A New War”, a spoof of
news-reporting of wars. John says that he now looks only for theater work that
is infused with laughter. The NY Times described the playwright as “one of
trenchant wit, irresistible goofiness and fierce commitment to nonpolitical
concepts like integrity, truth, critical thinking and the fabulousness of a
multi-colored world of many-splendored cultures.” Plenty of yuks.
John’s credits in the program outweigh
his fellow actors and range from The Fantasticks to Titanic to Macbeth.
In submitting his write-up for the Book, CHARLES “PETE” DAVIS
commented: “I deliberately refrained from digressing into
areas of philosophy and
politics, realizing that the Reunion Book was not meant to be filled entirely
with MY writings.” Pete also included a neat little couplet, ascribed to Kevin
Welch: “
There’ll be two dates on your tombstone,
and all your
friends will read ‘em,
but all that’ gonna
matter is,
that little
dash between ‘em.
PETE KENYON spent a little time on the phone with BILL REX (coming to
reunion) and determined that the Rex’s split their time between two totally
delightful locations,
North Carolina
(near
Asheville
) and
Ponte
Vedra Beach
,
FL
- a 7.5
hour commute.
JOAN ADAMS and the fisherman she regards as her husband, JIM, reported in
March that they were “resting up” on the beautiful
island
of
Ko Samui
in
Thailand
. From
there, they headed to
Myanmar
(formerly
Burma
). Jim
waxed poetic, quoting Kipling: “In all the world there is no place like
Burma
.” Not
all that poetic when you think about it. Be prepared for tales of wonder at
reunion.
I still hear occasionally from JOEL LASKY in
Dallas
, who
claims that strange, arcane and mysterious things happen to you when the
functioning of your body is assigned to a heart/lung machine. Since he and I
(and TED SHORT) underwent similar
mitral valve replacement surgery, I now find myself awake at
3 AM
, hearing
spectral flutterings in the darkness. Weird, but also a bit mind-bending.
Joel recently copied me on a note to DON KENNEDY, congratulating him on
winning gold in the Arizona Senior Olympics in men’s double-scull rowing.
Related story. A decade ago,
when i got into Masters throwing events, I found a tee-shirt that had a seated
athlete, in a Rodin-style pose, surrounded by throwing implements (shot, discus,
javelin, hammer, weight) and the slogan “I throw, therefore I am.” Wary that
a 260 pound shot-putter would brace me and demand to know the Latin for the
slogan (like Sartre’s “Scio ergo sum”), I sought out DAVE SICES, retired
head of the Romance Languages Department for advice.
We jointly rejected “hurlio” as being
too reminiscent of early Freshman year experiences with too much gin and finally
settled on “iacio”, ergo “Iacio ergo Sum.”Dave and JACQUELINE are nicely
retired to Chapel Hill, NC where they have free run of three university
libraries and facilities . Professor
Sices continues to maintain hopes for the life of the mind.
The following from SHELLY WOOLF bears a verbatim recital: “Just wanted
to let you know that i am now in the Football Hall of Fame. I was talking to RON
DOUGHERTY at this past February’s ‘54 golf outing in
Florida
and
realized he was not only from
Canton
,
Ohio
, but
Chief Legal Counsel for the Football hall of Fame. I told him that, at their
request, I was taking three of my grandsons to The Hall of Fame during their
spring vacation in April.
“Ron then talked about the place and mentioned that it is located in
Canton
because
that’s where Jim Thorpe played and that Thorpe is the focal point of the
institution. I related to Ron that, in the summer of 1952, Bernie Sudikoff
‘53, AARON MARGOLIS and I were working our way around the country and, on our
swing back East, we were living in a trailer on the road between
Las Vegas
and
Henderson
,
NV
. On our
way to work one day, we stopped at a dreary roadside tavern called “Jim
Thorpe’s All American Club.” In the dusky darkness in the place, we could
see his cleats, helmets and photos. Behind the bar in this deserted place was
the greatest athlete of the first half of the 20th century
with a handshake of steel.
“Jim asked where we were going and if we’d mind dropping him off at
the hospital o he could see his wife. The ride was long enough to hear his
philosophy of life, the value he put on competition and to gain his
encouragement to us to play fair and hard at whatever we did. If it had been a
script for a Knute Rockne movie, it couldn’t have been better. Thorpe died a
year later.
“Ron loved the story and had it videotaped when I was in
Canton
and it
is now a part of the Hall of Fame archives.”
We lost IRWIN HERRMAN in 1995. At the time, the newsletter reported the
magnificent tribute that had been paid Irwin for the extraordinary contributions
he had made to education in
Australia
. Last
year, i contacted HELEN, Irwin’s widow for some information on her and their
sons. Helen is Professor and Director of Psychiatry at the
University
of
Melbourne
: “I am
indeed a native of
Australia
and
Irwin and I met in
Oxford
,
England
when I
was a postgraduate student there in the mid 1970s. Irwin was working in the
University administration, having completed his DPhil in International Relations
before that. Irwin’s first son Colin and our two sons, Bruce and Alan were all
born in
Oxford
. Bruce
and Alan were brought up in
Australia
as we
moved back to my hometown of
Melbourne
when
they were young. My husband Greg and i now live in
Melbourne
while
the boys have scattered - for the time being at least. Bruce is a
Melbourne-trained lawyer who, for the last year and a half, has been working in
film post-production in
New York
. Alan is
a graduate in Economics and Commerce who has worked in
Melbourne
and is
now relocating to
London
. We
fortunately have opportunities to visit them from time to time.”
‘Round the girdl’d earth ......
If you are a television watcher, you have, on occasion been told to :
“Ask your doctor about ..... (a drug)”.
In February, JAY DAVIS was a member of a distinguished panel at The Tuck
School, discussing the escalating trend of direct-to-consumer advertising of
prescription drugs. An article in the Connecticut Valley Spectator about the
discussion began with the example of drugs for erectile dysfunction and a
television ad with the symbolic imagery of a football being thrown through a
suspended automobile tire. Jay was quoted often and the article mentioned that
he had been the managing director of the world’s largest medical advertising
agency at the time of the introduction of both Nicorette and Seldane (later
Allegra). The campaign for Seldane -
“.. you can put your symptoms to sleep and still stay awake” took sales of
the drug from $30 million to $800 million. The
descriptions of the changing relationships between doctors and patients today
can probably be acknowledged by most of you reading this story. Good topic for
chatter at the reunion Class tent.
Here’s another delightful PenPal story from LARRY TAYLOR: “For me
and, indeed, for my wife JEAN, the program has been a great success. Our penpals,
D. Bradley Bate and Chelsea Lane-Miller write often and with enthusiasm via
email. We’ve exchanged numerous messages and cards. Brad and Chelsea were a
good match for me as both of them are active in the DOC and outdoor activities
and are involved with environmental issues.
“Brad and Chelsea are very involved in campus activities and described
to us their many experiences. They clearly were interested in my Dartmouth
experiences too. I was impressed with how polite and gracious they have been to
me and Jean and they clearly sowed genuine interest and respect for us oldies.
“We had the opportunity to meet
Chelsea
in
person in
London
where
she was enrolled in the London School of Economics. Jean and i were
participating in a Dartmouth College Alumni educational tour to France and the
UK at the time. A panel presentation by London School of Economics professors
and Gene Lyons was arranged for us as part of the tour. The 15 or so Dartmouth
students at the school also attended. At a reception following the program, we
had a great opportunity to meet and talk with
Chelsea
.
“I was able to give Brad an idea for the Carnival sculpture and
provided him, visa the Internet, with photos of the ‘53 and ‘54 sculptures.
Brad, among others, successfully revived student participation in this project
after a lack of interest over recent years.
“I am sure that we will continue correspondence with Brad and Chelsea
after they graduate.” Sounds like the perfect embodiment of what the PenPal
program was meant to be. The matching of common interests was an obvious plus in
this case.
Class Connector JAY DAVIS on ‘54 skiing: “We had our best turnout yet
for the
Vermont
event at
Mt.
Snow
. New to
the group were JACK CHRISTY (Philadelphia), TOM TYLER (Florida) and BOB ADNOPOZ
(New Haven). The regular hard core included DICK and ELLEN GORSEY, NED FREEDMAN,
PHIL COOKE, JOHN and GRETCHEN MORAN, DANA and ANNE LOW, DICK PEARL and myself.
Good skiing and good times at Ned’s apres-ski house. Aspen/Vail was smaller
because of health problems, but still attracted Gorsey, Freedman, Tyler, Adnopoz,
STEVE MULLINS and family and myself. Typical
Colorado
skiing
with a little warm weather.”
In Memoriam
GRANT JOSEPH GRUEL, JR.
“Joe” Gruel died in
Naples
,
FL
on April
5th after a prolonged battle with prostate cancer. He joined us in Hanover from
Jamestown High School in Lakewood, NY (coincidentally a classmate of
FRANNIE MORRISON). Freshman year he was combined, alphabetically , in
Russell Sage with RALPH GRIFFIN and GEORGE GRABOYS. He was a brother of SAE and,
according to his Reflections writeup, more of an enjoyer of the “Dartmouth
Experience” than a student, leaving after two-and-a-half years for military
service in the
US
and
Japan
. With
two more years of maturity under his belt, he returned to campus and graduated
in 1956. Then it was “Katie bar the door!” as he burst into the rest of his
life and made a sizable impression.
First, let me suggest that you read his Reflections submission of 25
years ago, just to bring you up to the speed of this most extraordinary man.
Thanks to both SKIP WEYMOUTH and DICK BARKER, I have two articles on
Grant (he apparently shucked off “Joe” somewhere along the line) and have
chosen the more lively one to celebrate his life - from the Grand Rapids Press:
“In the courtroom, Grant Gruel’s head always was in the game. He
exuded confidence and his cut-to-the chase questioning style kept jurors
interested. But the man so passionate about law was among the most
down-to-earth, connecting with people in an uncanny way, whether on the golf
course or with his grandchildren, his widow said.
‘Within his grandeur, he was a modest man’, said MARY E. HOLLAND
GRUEL from their winter home in
Naples
, FL.
‘As much as a lot of people knew him as the lawyer and that role, he had a
very warm, compassionate side that everyone loved.’
Mr. Gruel was long considered one of the state’s top trial attorneys.
Some two weeks prior to his passing, he dictated a letter to his wife: ‘Every
remaining day gives me additional insight into the elements of
love, friendship and the essence of life’, he said. “
The article goes on to say that some of his golfing buddies, at his
request, are planting two very troublesome Pin Oaks on the second hole at
Cascade Country Club in his honor - one that will bring Joe to mind when less
than straight drives are rejected by the trees.
Grant’s law firm accepted trial cases from both sides of process and
fought with might to win for their clients. Grant’s most famous case involved
his defense of a police detective charged with the shooting of his wife, a
judge. He won the case, based on a “befogged with alcohol” premise, but the
detective went to jail anyhow for firing at the police in the aftermath of the
killing. Grant told the press that he didn’t sweat the case - “Trials have
never been a heavy stress item for me.”
One of his partners reported that Grant slowed in his work in the late
90s and quietly retired in 2002. “He loved the law and everything it meant. He
just enjoyed the whole process of it. So we feed off that, too. He taught us
many things.”
Grant is survived by his wife, Mary, four children from previous
marriages, his wife’s children and three grandchildren.
PGBarker54@aol.com
(203) 661-7611

June 1954. Cliff Evans' marriage to Mary-Anne Treene
was overrun by 54's
(Click on photo to see a larger version); click 'Back' button
to return here)